patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Bare Knuckle Political Brawling Comes To District 2 Council Race

The latest brouhaha surrounds whether Jim Eyre called Brookhaven a "cancer," right here on Brookhaven Patch.

 


Brookhaven’s District 2 city council race has gotten especially nasty over the final few days of campaigning.

At issue over the past week is a flier recently sent to voters implying that candidate Jim Eyre called Brookhaven a “cancer.” The mailer came from Start Brookhaven Right, a newly incorporated organization

Eyre said the mailer takes comments he made in a March 30, 2011, Patch article entitled “Brookhaven Cityhood: The Answer Or Band-Aid?”, out of context.

Eyre’s quote from Patch opinion article reads, “Realizing this it becomes glaringly obvious that the idea of cityhood, while appealing, is only a band-aid cure on a cancer that will continue to eat away at our wallets.”

Eyre concluded the article with, “Unless we can force substantive changes in how DeKalb County spends our tax dollars, we will never realize the tax savings [state] Rep. [Mike] Jacobs so gleefully dangled in front of us as an underlying incentive for his city movement”.

Eyre is accusing another candidate, Russell Mitchell, of playing a role in the mailer. He said Mitchell’s former employer, Florida-based Calvin, Giordano & Associates, is a major donor for Start Brookhaven Right, which mailed the flier to voters.

Calvin, Giordano & Associates provides municipal services to cities and currently manages the city of Dunwoody's financial and administrative operations through an outsourced contract.

“I believe accepting pay to play in any form is the most egregious mistake an elected official can make and there will be no place for such activities in Brookhaven,” said Eyre.

Another candidate, Larry Hurst, is also seeking the District 2 seat.

Over the past year, Calvin, Giordano & Associates, Inc., has donated $10,000 to BrookhavenYES; $2,500 to Start Brookhaven Right, Inc; and $2,500 to Mitchell’s campaign, according to the Georgia Government Transparancy and Campaign Finance Commission.

Mitchell was also a board member for BrookhavenYES.

“This is a ridiculous conspiracy theory from a desperate candidate," said Mitchell. “I have absolutely nothing to do with the Start Brookhaven Right group. The first I heard of them is when I got mail from them."

"As far as the contribution from my former employer is concerned, Jim Eyre knows that it is perfectly legal to accept corporate contributions and the voters of district 2 should be proud that my former employer thought enough of my work to believe in my campaign."

Mitchell also said Eyre’s financial disclosure “is filled with DeKalb County vendors and companies that currently do business with the county and surrounding cities.

“Furthermore, his campaign is plagued with contributions from zoning attorneys and politicians. The last few days of this campaign seem to be focused on who is funding who's campaign. I am confident that voters will be much more comfortable with my supporters and contributors than his."

Related Items:

Brookhaven Residents Create 'Start Brookhaven Right' Committee.

Brookhaven Cityhood: The Answer Or A Band-Aid?

"The Brookhaven Name Resonates With Everyone."

Your Complete Brookhaven And Chamblee Elections Guide.

About this column: News and information about politics in our community. Related Topics: brookhaven elections

Steve Walker

3:19 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Remember, it wasn't but a few short months ago that Jim, Sandy and their other NO City buddies were running around the area preaching their "Politics 101" rhetoric.
Oh, how the times have changed................or have they ?

Reply

Steve Walker

3:40 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

A previous post here on the Patch is a little reminder of those days we all remember from the very recent past.
http://brookhaven.patch.com/articles/some-candidates-are-descendents-of-no-city-brookhaven

Reply

Low and Behold

3:44 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

I agree the Cancer line used that way amounts to a lie.

But then so does Sandy Murray's lines. The latest exposed lie is her lie about J. Max's gun that was stolen. He had the serial #, but of course it was at his house. He phoned it in and the gun was later recovered. Add that to her lies about J. Max and the Johnson Ferry flood plain and her sill J. Max tip line and the doctored pictures of J. Max on her mailouts. Wow she makes these District 2 people look like boy scouts.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Thomas T Telford

4:03 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

If you knew anything Chewy, he was AT HIS HOUSE AND THE GUN WAS STOLEN THERE!

Comment_arrow

Low and Behold

4:07 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Are you saying he didn't go in after filing the report and call it in later? Really TTT? Is that what you are saying? TTT be honest. Don't lie.

Comment_arrow

Tired of Stupiditytired

4:46 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Telford stole the very handle he is using...he is a lie.

Sandy the liar

4:08 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Wow Thomas are you one of those sending false tip to Sandy M's shady tip line? You must live next door or something. The all caps gives your temper away. Maybe because the gun was stolen he is responsible for the crime as well. As a matter of fact all theft and crime is the fault of the victim. Your tip doesn't pan out buddy.

Reply

Eddie E.

4:27 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

I guess this was inevitable.

As soon as the 'approved candidates' realized they would face REAL opposition, they just started to make stuff up.

Another layer of government and nothing is really different.

Reply

Thomas T Telford

4:57 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Show me the report.
J Max's irresponsibility endangered our community.

Reply

Kestrel Larson

5:00 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

What happened to our community?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

5:04 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

The 'approved' people were not in charge, and they will destroy everything to ensure they someday become in charge.

Comment_arrow

Steve Walker

5:05 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

You could always start another petition to find out.

A Resident

5:16 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Zanny Murray keeps touting her success as a small business owner. I've tried unsuccessfully to locate her business dba Computer Essentials. There is a computer repair shop in Madison Georgia with that name, but I can't locate anything else. Even her financial disclosure fails to list the business. Is this just another in a long list of fabrications?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

5:31 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

residue,
Oversleep this afternoon?

HamBurger

5:25 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

OK, I am a little confused . . . So Mr. Russell has forgotten his Brookhaven Yes days? Has he forgotten Shannon Cameron? Chris Elsevier?

Start Brookhaven Right, Inc.: “The committee chairperson is listed as Shannon Cameron, who served as a board member for Brookhaven YES and is currently the vice president of the Nancy Creek Heights Neighborhood Network. SBR's treasurer is Christopher Elsevier, who served as treasurer for Brookhaven YES and is an executive officer of The Piedmont Bank.”

And Mr. Russell actually expects us to believe the following statement?

Mr. Russell: “This is a ridiculous conspiracy theory from a desperate candidate," said Mitchell. “I have absolutely nothing to do with the Start Brookhaven Right group. The first I heard of them is when I got mail from them."

Clearly, it is not about the taxpaying citizens of the new city of Brookhaven, it is all about the desperate Mr. Russell! Hey! Cast your vote for Mr. Russell and we will get what we deserve!

Please pass the yellow mustard!

Reply
Comment_arrow

HamBurger

5:27 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

This is like saying Brookhaven Yes and Brookhaven Ballot Committee have nothing in common when there was commonality in their contributors and officers!

Please pass the yellow mustard!

Comment_arrow

HamBurger

5:28 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Ain’t small town life just peachy!

Please pass the yellow mustard!

Phil

5:42 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Wow-- like saying Jim Eyre has not misrepresented himself at Dekalb when stopping three (3) neighbors from installing a pool in their yards--but leading Dekalb to believe he was representing the Ashford Park Association.

Wonder if he will represent Brookhaven as a Council Member--or his own personal opinions? Hmmmmm...........

All this talk is like saying Jim is easy to work with. LOL. I pity the other three Council members who will find out quickly how difficult he will be.

Jim wants to see Sandy Murray get elected (which says alot in and of itself), but it brings up the question that Mr. Eyre has made no secret that he detests another Mayoral candidate--who just may win.

Nice start.....

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

6:16 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Dude,
You are way to attached to the mythic pool aren't you.

Comment_arrow

Prissy Mae Millendorf, Brookhaven Socialite

8:03 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

And just what are you attached to Edvard? Smoky cigar butts!

Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

9:30 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Fuzzy Mae,
Where do you dredge up this nonsense?

A Resident

5:44 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

The Movers & Shakers of Brookhaven have aligned to support Zanny Murray: Cousins = $4,500, Imlay = $4,500 and the Wannabees Ehlert, Cobb, Benton. Is the Capital City Club looking to expand and in need of a friend to help with zoning? Zanny has beaten J Max and his measly $500 contribution from a four small companies. Zanny = bought and paid for by Brookhaven elite.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

6:15 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Could you put that into cogent English so it is more easily discredited.

Or is it too late on Friday afternoon to expect cogency?

Comment_arrow

Prissy Mae Millendorf, Brookhaven Socialite

8:06 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Could you take off your "dunce" hat Edvard and start thinking for the first time in your life. The elite are financing her campaign! I believe we all know what she's made of... Political puppetry!

Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

9:31 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Fuzzy Mae,

At least your disjoint flights of fantasy provide a good laugh now and then.
Avoidance of 'puppetry' is the only reason I remain involved.

Phil

6:18 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

When did Murray get those contributions, A Resident? I checked last week and did not see the Cousins and Imlay ones. That is curious. What would those two contributors possibly want to PAY to PLAY for?

Sounds corrupt to me.

I mean, Cousins could be looking for approval for another development in the Brookhaven footprint--or wants to grease the wheels for any problems with the new City and their already build developments.

Could you provide a link to that info, A Resident?

Tia

Reply
Comment_arrow

Low and Behold

6:39 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Wow, talk about calling the kettle black. Does Sandy have no Shame?

Comment_arrow

Low and Behold

6:41 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

With that money Sandy Murray can probably buy a better No City sign. Preferably made out of something other than black garbage bags.

http://brookhaven.patch.com/articles/some-candidates-are-descendents-of-no-city-brookhaven#comments

Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

9:32 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

ferdie,
When you have nothing, you still persist.
This is more than a little sad, don't you think?

Patch_comments_icon

Timothy Darnell

6:27 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Any comments that speculate on posters' identities will be removed. Continued comments could result in the suspension of a user's account.

Reply

Kathie " Straight Outta Compton" Coy

6:59 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Tim, where have YOU been all week? lol You need a maid, because you have LOTS of housekeeping to do!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Prissy Mae Millendorf, Brookhaven Socialite

8:10 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

That's for sure Ms. Coy... He catches very few... Wonder why? And please don't use the line that he has limited time to do so... Because many complain and bring them forward but nothing is done in many instances!

Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

9:34 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

Fuzzy Mae,
Of course, this would be much easier if the ADULTS in our tawdry little burg would just USE THEIR OWN NAMES unless their cowardice prevents them from speaking publicly.

Kathie " Straight Outta Compton" Coy

8:41 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

I don't so much blame Tim as I do the high ups who keep snatching our editors out from under us every three months. Where are our hall monitors when we need them?

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

9:34 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

I am still waiting on them to provide me with the contact information for 'just wondering', so I can sue him/her/it.

A Resident

11:01 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

What a piece of work. Zanny gets her money from the elite of Brookhaven and Jim Eyer gets his money from real estate attorneys and agents. "Pay for access" or something more sinister. Tom & Ann Cousins and John & Mary Ellen Imlay should be embarrassed that there money is being used to buy such sleazy campaign material. Did Jody Cobb and Carolyn Benton design the material, there contributions were 'in kind'. Maybe J Max should take Politic 101, he only received $500 per contribution Zanny got $5,000 per family.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

10:46 am on Saturday, November 3, 2012

residue,
Keep beating that drum.
You don't seem to be aware of the hollow sound that emanates.

Brookhaven Maven

11:21 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

If this first election is any indication of the way the new city is going to run, then we are all in deep s**t. This kind of negative campaigning ranks right up there with Elaine Boyer and Vernon Jones.

How can anyone honestly say becoming a city does not give us another layer of government? If it doesn't, then why in the world are we being subjected to all this?

-- The Maven

Reply
Comment_arrow

John Q Public

6:50 am on Saturday, November 3, 2012

And how did you vote on the cityhood referendum?

Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

11:52 am on Saturday, November 3, 2012

One would hope he/she voted AGAINST it.
Like Citizens in Districts 2,3 and 4.

Brookhaven Maven

11:34 pm on Friday, November 2, 2012

To A Residue @ 5:16pm --

You are right to question Ms. Murray's claims about her business experience. I have previously addressed this in another thread on this forum. See my remarks at the bottom of this post.

In addition to that earlier response, you may also find the information at the following web sites to be interesting:
http://www.yatedo.com/p/Sandy+Murray/normal/458eaa8c8aab1138280ad2afefe60e22

http://twitter.com/slm3212

-- The Maven

(Original comment below.)
8:49 pm on Saturday, October 6, 2012
To Maggie Anderson @ 12:54, Lucie KS @ 4:03 and others ---

Regarding Sandy Murray and her business experience: Briefly being a franchisee for a kids' art instruction company called Abrakadoodle does not qualify Ms. Murray to run a (potentially) 30 million dollar city. Being an owner of a computer instruction company (Computer Essentials / Business Computer Essentials) in the early 1980's certainly doesn't add much to her track record. Being a Kaplan SAT tutor certainly doesn't do much for her skillset to be the first mayor of the city. We deserve better!

-- The Maven

Reply

A Resident

9:47 am on Saturday, November 3, 2012

As with so much of her materiel, Zanny Murray fabricates statements. She may have been a small business owner, but there is no proof it was successful. Zanny also states she is the 'only' small business owner. It seems to me that J Max Davis has a law firm with employees and is currently in business. Maybe a small item, but Zanny's strategy seems to be 'ignore the facts and say anything over and over again"

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

10:48 am on Saturday, November 3, 2012

Did the trollmasters give you an extra nickel for every time you stuffed 'zanny' into an otherwise pointless sentence?

Justin Turner

1:45 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

As an outside observer... it is hilarious to see that the "Start Brookhaven Right" folks can't even interpret Mr. Eyre's metaphor "right"! It should clear to anyone who has taken high school english that "Brookhaven Cityhood" is the "Bandaid"... over the "cancer" that is Dekalb County government mismanagement.

Yes this is obvious, which leads me to my point... whoever is behind this group is obviously not that intelligent, or is simply dishonest (No surpise given the former "brookhaven yessers" in the group). Therefore, I would suggest to those who get to vote, to cast their vote for whomever is not this group's preferred candidate.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Eddie E.

4:09 pm on Tuesday, November 6, 2012

Follow that simple rule for all 'former yesser' candidates.

Leave a comment